Use my Roth IRA to clean the slate?

Clean slate - shutterstock_53976814Q: Should I redeem my ROTH IRA to pay off large amount of debt? I got laid off over a year ago. I accrued just over $15,000 in credit card debt dur­ing that time (some of that included med­ical bills). Inter­est rate on credit card is almost 17%. I will only make aprx. $38,000/year. Raise in future not likely. I have $250,000 in a tra­di­tional IRA that I won’t touch. I have $18,000 in a ROTH IRA. Am I best off redeem­ing the ROTH to pay off credit card debt and start new year off with a clean slate — and cut­ting up the credit card? Or am I bet­ter off tak­ing a few years to pay off card? I can only pay about $400 towards card each month (and that’s only because I live at home, oth­er­wise would be even less). Many thanks for your response.

–Bren­nan, Tennessee

A: I’m sorry to hear about your lay­off and I hope things are going bet­ter for you.

Not a Sim­ple Deci­sion
As for whether or not you should use your Roth IRA to elim­i­nate your debt, I’m afraid the answer isn’t as straight­for­ward as either of us would like. On one hand, it’s gen­er­ally a bad idea to use retire­ment funds for any­thing other than retire­ment. On the other hand, liv­ing under a crush­ing bur­den of high inter­est rate debt can be prob­lem­atic from a qual­ity of life per­spec­tive and, as you’ve pointed out, it can also be a bad finan­cial move given the money wasted on inter­est expense.

So what do you do?

Usu­ally a Bad Idea
I’ll start by say­ing that for me, using the Roth IRA would be com­pletely off the table if you aren’t com­pletely sure your days of incur­ring con­sumer debt are over. There’s noth­ing to be gained by using retire­ment funds to pay off debt and then run­ning up the debt again. Also, you need to under­stand that even though your reg­u­lar Roth IRA con­tri­bu­tions can be with­drawn at any time with­out taxes or penal­ties, the same can­not be said for earn­ings in the account. If you with­drawal them before age 59 ½ you’re gen­er­ally going to have to pay taxes and a 10% penalty. Finally, elim­i­nat­ing a valu­able finan­cial plan­ning tool like a Roth IRA isn’t some­thing to be taken lightly. You could very well regret giv­ing up the poten­tial for tax-free retire­ment income when the time comes. It’s for all of these rea­sons (and more) that I typ­i­cally tell peo­ple not to do what you’re con­tem­plat­ing. It really is a bad idea most of the time.

Some­times It Can Work
Hav­ing said all of that though, I also have to admit that it’s pos­si­ble your sit­u­a­tion might be dif­fer­ent than most. Even though I wouldn’t rec­om­mend it, I have seen peo­ple play the slate-cleaning game and have things turn out okay. Are you in that group? Unfor­tu­nately, there’s no way for either of us to know in advance. That’s a gam­ble that only you can decide if you should take. If you do decide to take it, just be sure to check with a CPA or other qual­i­fied tax advi­sor first to make sure you fully under­stand the tax implications.

Thank you so much for your ques­tion. I real­ize I didn’t give you a defin­i­tive answer but I hope the thoughts I’ve offered here are help­ful for you in decid­ing what to do and I wish you all the best.


USAA or its affiliates do not provide tax advice. Taxpayers should seek advice based upon their own particular circumstances from an independent tax advisor. The information is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended to substitute for obtaining professional financial advice. Please thoroughly research and seek professional representation before acting on any information you may have found in this article. This article is in no way attempts to provide advice that relates all personal circumstances.

Examples given are hypothetical illustrations and not an indication of the benefits or features of any USAA product. You should seek policies and advice based upon your own particular circumstances. Sample loans are for illustration purposes only and are not a rate quote, pre-approval, or commitment to lend.

Scott Halliwell and JJ Montanaro are CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ practitioners with USAA Financial Planning Services, one of the USAA family of companies. Certified Financial Planner Board of Standards, Inc. owns the certification marks CFP® and Certified Financial Planner™ in the United States, which it awards to individuals who successfully complete CFP Board's initial and ongoing certification requirements.

USAA Financial Planning Services® refers financial planning services and financial advice provided by USAA Financial Planning Services Insurance Agency, Inc. USAA Financial Planning Services Insurance Agency, Inc. (known as USAA Financial Insurance Company in California, Lic. #0E36312), a registered investment adviser and insurance agency and its wholly owned subsidiary, USAA Financial Advisors, Inc., a registered broker dealer. (known as USAA Financial Insurance Agency in California), a registered investment adviser and insurance agency and its wholly owned subsidiary, USAA Financial Advisors, Inc., a registered broker dealer.

USAA means United Services Automobile Association and its affiliates. Investments provided by USAA Investment Management Company and USAA Financial Advisors Inc., both registered broker dealers. Banking products provided by USAA Federal Savings Bank. Credit cards provided by USAA Savings Bank. Both Banks Member FDIC.